Arrest made by South Dakota police in death of Cazenovia woman

The tests showed that Fischer had a blood alcohol content of .23 — or more than twice the legal limit — and also had marijuana in his system, according to police.

“We were waiting for the blood [tests] to come back; we can’t make an arrest without the facts,” Welsh said in explanation of why Fischer’s arrest occurred 11 days after the accident. “It was what we suspected [i.e. DWI] and he was charged.”

Gregg and Susan Spindler, the parents of Maegan Spindler and Cazenovia residents, issued a statement after Fischer’s arrest calling it, “very distressing that [Fischer] was still at large [after the accident], especially after learning the sheriff did not have power to arrest him on tribal lands. The family of Maegan Spindler is thankful and relieved this has happened; if authorities would have had to go and arrest him, it would have been a more drawn-out process and could have resulted in violence.”

The Spindlers said they expect further charges to be brought against Fischer.

Fischer was charged with two counts of vehicular homicide, a felony, one for each victim. Each charge carries a maximum sentence of up to 15 years in prison.

Fischer has not been charged with DWI at present because the main criteria for a vehicular homicide charge is that the driver was under the influence of alcohol or drugs when a victim was killed, and the felony homicide charges carry greater penalties, Welsh said. However, the charges against Fischer can be amended in the future to include DWI if the state’s attorney decides to do so, he said.

According to reporting by the Argus Leader, Fischer has previous convictions in South Dakota for possession of marijuana, five instances of alcohol possession by a minor and convictions for driving without a license, failure to use proper child restraints and failure to get his children to school.

Maegan Spindler, who had a bachelor’s degree in wildlife science from SUNY ESF and a fisheries diploma in 2011 from Vancouver Island University, was planning to start graduate school in 2014 to continue work on native fish species.

A funeral service was held for her Sunday, July 14, in the Oran Community Church in Oran.

Jason Emerson is editor of the Cazenovia Republican. He can be reached at editor@cazenoviarepublican.com.

Vote on this Story by clicking on the Icon


Use the comment form below to begin a discussion about this content.

Sign in to comment